Team 
Team Awards Team MVP
Team Awards Team MVP
| 1961 | Bill Mathis, Running Back | 2000 | Curtis Martin, Running Back |
| 1962 | Dick Christy, Running Back | 2001 | Curtis Martin, Running Back |
| 1963 | Bake Turner, Wide Receiver | 2002 | Chad Pennington, Quaterback |
| 1964 | Dainard Paulson, Safety | 2003 | Santana Moss, Wide Receiver |
| 1965 | Matt Snell, Fullback | 2004 | Curtis Martin, Running Back |
| 1966 | George Sauer, Wide Receiver | 2005 | Jonathan Vilma, Linebacker |
| 1967 | Don Maynard, Wide Receiver | 2006 | Laveranues Coles, Wide Receiver |
| 1968 | Joe Namath, Quarterback | 2007 | Leon Washington, Running Back |
| 1969 | Joe Namath, Quarterback | 2008 | Thomas Jones, Running Back |
| 1970 | John Elliott, Defensive Tackle | 2009 | Darrelle Revis, Cornerback |
| 1971 | Larry Grantham, Linebacker | ||
| 1972 | John Riggins, Fullback | ||
| 1973 | Emerson Boozer, Fullback | ||
| 1974 | Joe Namath, Quarterback | ||
| 1975 | John Riggins, Fullback | ||
| 1976 | Clark Gaines, Fullback | ||
| 1977 | Randy Rasmussen, Offensive Guard | ||
| 1978 | Wesley Walker, Wide Receiver | ||
| 1979 | Marvin Powell, Offensive Tackle | ||
| 1980 | Bruce Harper, Running Back | ||
| 1981 | Richard Todd, Quarterback | ||
| 1982 | Freeman McNeil, Running Back | ||
| 1983 | Lance Mehl, Linebacker | ||
| 1984 | Freeman McNeil, Running Back | ||
| 1985 | Ken O'Brien, Quarterback | ||
| 1986 | Al Toon, Wide Receiver | ||
| 1987 | Al Toon, Wide Receiver | ||
| 1988 | Al Toon, Wide Receiver | ||
| 1989 | JoJo Townsell, Wide Receiver | ||
| 1990 | Pat Leahy, Kicker | ||
| 1991 | Chris Burkett, Wide Receiver | ||
| 1992 | Brian Washington, Strong Safety | ||
| 1993 | Johnny Johnson, Running Back | ||
| 1994 | Mo Lewis, Linebacker | ||
| 1995 | Marvin Jones, Linebacker | ||
| 1996 | Adrian Murrell, Running Back | ||
| 1997 | Mo Lewis, Linebacker | ||
| 1998 | Vinny Testaverde, Quarterback | ||
| 1999 | Curtis Martin, Running Back |