Team 
NFL Pro Bowler
NFL Pro Bowler
| 1970 | DT John Elliot, T Winston Hill |
| 1971 | T Winston Hill |
| 1972 | TE Richard Caster, T Winston Hill, QB Joe Namath |
| 1973 | TE Jerome Barkum, T Winston Hill, |
| 1974 | TE Richard Caster, |
| 1975 | TE Richard Caster, FB John Riggins, |
| 1978 | WR Wesley Walker |
| 1979 | T Marvin Powell |
| 1980 | T Marvin Powell |
| 1981 | C Joe Fields, DE Mark Gastineau, DE Joe Klecko, T Marvin Powell |
| 1982 | C Joe Fields, DE Mark Gastineau, RB Freeman McNeil, T Marvin Powell, WR Wesley Walker, |
| 1983 | DE Mark Gastineau, DE Joe Klecko, T Marvin Powell |
| 1984 | DE Mark Gastineau, DE Joe Klecko, RB Freeman McNeil, |
| 1985 | DE Mark Gastineau, DE Joe Klecko, RB Freeman McNeil, LB Lance Mehl, QB Ken O´Brien, |
| 1986 | TE Mickey Shuler, WR Al Toon, |
| 1987 | WR Al Toon, |
| 1988 | S Erik McMillian, TE Mickey Shuler, WR Al Toon, |
| 1989 | S Erik McMillian, |
| 1991 | QB Ken O´Brien, |
| 1993 | QB Boomer Esiason, |
| 1994 | WR Rob Moore, |
| 1997 | CB Aaron Glenn, |
| 1998 | CB Aaron Glenn, WR K. Johnson, LB Mo Lewis, RB Curtis Martin, QB Vinny Testaverde, |
| 1999 | WR Keyshawn Johnson, LB Mo Lewis, C Kevin Mawae, P Tom Tupa, |
| 2000 | FB Richie Anderson, LB Mo Lewis, C Kevin Mawae, |
| 2001 | DE John Abraham, RB Curtis Martin, C Kevin Mawae |
| 2002 | DE John Abraham, C Kevin Mawae |
| 2003 | DE Shaun Ellis, C Kevin Mawae |
| 2004 | DE John Abraham , C Kevin Mawae, RB Curtis Martin |
| 2005 | CB Ty Law, LB Jonathan Vilma |
| 2006 | KR Justin Miller |
| 2007 | wurde niemand gewählt |
| 2008 | RB Thomas Jones, G Alan Faneca, DT Kris Jenkins, KR Leon Washington, QB Brett Favre, C Nick Mangold, CB Darrelle Revis |
| 2009 | G Alan Faneca, C Nick Mangold, CB Darrelle Revis, T D'Brickashaw Ferguson |