Team 
AFL All Stars
AFL All Stars
| 1961 | QB Al Dorow, S Dick Felt, RB Bill Mathis, G Bob Mischak |
| 1962 | RB Dick Christy, LB Larry Grantham, G Bob Mischak |
| 1963 | LB Larry Grantham, RB Bill Mathis, WR Bake Tumer |
| 1964 | LB Larry Grantham, T Winston Hill, S Dainard Paulson, T Sherman Plunkett, FB Matt Snell |
| 1965 | WR Don Maynard, QB Joe Namath, S Dainard Paulson |
| 1966 | DE Verlon Biggs, RB Emerson Boozer, LB Larry Grantham, T Sherman Plunkett, FB Matt Snell |
| 1967 | DE Verlon Biggs, LB Larry Grantham, T Winston Hill, TE Pete Lammons, WR Don Maynard, QB Joe Namath, WR George Sauer, |
| 1968 | LB Al Atkinson, DE Verlon Biggs, RB Emerson Boozer, DT John Elliott, G Dave Herman, T Winston Hill, WR Don Maynard, QB Joe Namath, DE Gerry Philbin, WR George Sauer, |
| 1969 | DT John Elliot, LB Larry Grantham, G Dave Herman, T Winston Hill, WR Don Maynard, QB Joe Namath,DE Gerry Philbin, WR George Sauer, FB Matt Snell, K Jim Turner |